The Feminization of Sexual Violence in Media Campaigns

I find it increasingly interesting in that whenever the conversation of rape is bought up, the first question always begins with the assumption that the victim is female: “Where was she when it happened?” “How serious was it?” “Will she be pressing charges”? Although it holds true that on average sexual violence is committed against women more than it is committed on men, it does not take away from the fact that media outlets and campaigns targeting youths and raising awareness by educating them fail to account for the fact that males are victims of rape as well. Aulette and Wittner also begin their chapter on sexual violence by outlining cases of violence against women in the Middle East as well as outlining how women who are victims of sexual violence are usually harmed by people that they know (257). As a result, youths are not educated on this and steps are not taken in order to prevent male rape.

 

            Out of the 3 blog posts thus far, there has been discussion on sexual violence pertaining mostly to the topic of female victims of rape. Out of the 3 blog posts, only one has discussed sexual violence with a male (transgendered female-male) as the victim. Aulette and Wittner also outline how men are in fact victimized in public places more than women (267). Thus, I will be dedicating this blog post to address the media’s lack of attentiveness to sexual violence towards male victims and it’s implications.

 

            Below is a video for a campaign for New Zealand entitled “Who Are You?”. The video explains steps that people can take in order to prevent their friend or someone they know from getting raped. The referent person in the video who is the victim is inevitably a girl. The video immediately focuses on tactics in which we can prevent girls from getting raped. Furthermore, in the video it is a male who is the perpetrator of the sexual aggression however it is perfectly viable to say that women are too capable of performing rape. This idea that men are the only one’s who can perform rape or are never the victims of rape is a sexual double standard and needs to be addressed.

 http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=9zr1oxEbdsw

            Discourses on prison rape can be taken into account. What is different about prison rape is that the perpetrator and the victim are always the same sex due the sexual separation in prisons. In male prisons we can observe that here both the victim and the perpetrator are males, whether or not they identify as queer is another story. In women prisons, it is the same paradigm, where both the perpetrator and victim are the same gender. However, the media knowingly does not express how men can be victims and women can be perpetrators and I feel that it is both necessary and useful to understand this when discussing discourses on sexual aggression and rape culture.

 

I feel that having women always portrayed as the victim “feminizes” rape and can really be harmful in terms of trying to really get down to the root of the problem. What needs to be figured out is not why women get raped but why perpetrators choose to rape regardless of if they are male or female or whether the victim is male or female.

 

Works Cited
Aulette, Judy Root and Judith Wittner. Gendered Worlds. 2nd Edition. New York       City: Oxford University Press, 2012.

The Assault after the Assault

Trigger Warning: post discusses rape of a transgendered youth

In the previous blog entries on this page, fellow bloggers mentioned the importance of promoting a supportive and safe environment for survivors of sexual violence upon reporting their crimes. The lack of support for these individuals is one of the main reasons that only an estimated one third of the acts of sexual violence that occur are reported (Aulette and Wittner 261).

One particular case of sexual and gendered violence that exemplifies the continued mistreatment of rape survivors and debunks many myths about sexual assault is the case of Brandon Teena, as described by the movie Boys Don’t Cry and the truthful events behind it. 

Brandon Teena was a transgendered (female to male) young adult in Humbolt, Nebraska in the early 90s. Because Brandon was living as a male, when it was discovered that he was biologically female, his acquaintances ‘took offense’ and violently assaulted him multiple times, resulting in his rape and murder.

Brandon Teena’s case is one of the many examples of men committing sexually violent acts on others as ‘punishment’. Aulette and Wittner describe that men’s capacity for violence helps validate their masculinity and in these instances they ‘assert their masculinity’ and in their minds are punishing the culprit for ‘causing harm and offense’ to their loved ones.

Upon discovery of Brandon’s birth-assigned sex, two of his male acquaintances tore off his pants to investigate if he had male or female anatomy to determine, in their minds, whether he was male or female. With this act, he fell prey to the “not-rape” epidemic that author Latoya Peterson discusses. Although he was sexually exposed violently, he was not raped at this instance, and did not report it initially because, like many who fall into this misinformed trap, he did not know what there was to report. 

The is bureaucratic ignorance of this epidemic as well because, as seen when Brandon reported the incident and was met with disbelief that because the attacker “hadn’t stuck his finger in [Brandon]” upon realizing his female anatomy. Because there was no ‘rape’ to consider, the police mostly disregarded his story as something likely fabricated.

Victim blaming is a highly prevalent attitude in rape cases where, instead of arguing that the rapist should not rape, many people say the survivor should must have been doing something wrong. In the case of Brandon Teena, victim blaming and lack of sensitivity by police enforcement are extremely visible. Upon reporting the brutal rape, Brandon was grilled by the police about his so called “sexual identity crisis”, rather than the details of his assault. The police department seemed uninterested in the pain and fright that Brandon was facing, and continued to pester him with questions like “why do you hang around with those boys seeing that you’re a girl?” that threw the blame of the assault on him. 

 Image

Hillary Swank as Brandon Teena from ‘Boys Don’t Cry’ being harassed in police questioning.

As with seen with many cases, like the Steubenville case mentioned by xoxo Gossip Girl, the police chose to believe that the men could ‘hardly help themselves’  and had reasons behind their actions that were received with pity by the law enforcement and public instead of punishment. The neglect of the police directly resulted in the further assault of Brandon Teena. The police first took excessive time to question the perpetrators on hearing of the crime, mysteriously ‘lost’ the rape kit that proved the guilt of the men and looked past all of the other evidence that suggested the assault took place. The checks and balances of the police bureau were hardly effective in that one man of the law decided that the two criminals did not seem guilty and actively prevented other officers from pursuing the case. 

Needless to say, Brandon, upon reporting, like many other survivors of assault, felt even less safe than when he has first faced the crime because of the blatant disregard for his continued safety by the police. Ignoring the previous criminal records of the perpetrators, Brandon was not protected by the police in any fashion. The department allowed the accused to continue to live their lives under no surveillance and Brandon was not placed under any form of protective watch. This ultimately allowed the rapists to hunt down Brandon in the safety of his own friends’ home and murder him.

The creation of gender expectations is a cause for gendered violence and the ‘differences’ of individuals make them more susceptible to sexual violence than those who blend into the crowd. This type of violence feeds off of the energy and implied acceptance of the state. By the state institutions not swiftly shutting down acts of violence and harassing the victims of sexual assault, perpetrators feel it is more likely that they will get away with the crime. They are then more likely to commit the crime if they believe they are less than likely to be punished for it.

Unfortunately, rape survivors are often discouraged from reporting the crimes committed against them because of the stigma of being a ‘rape victim’ that follows. This and the continued ignorance and blame by the police department causes them to feel unsafe and unprotected from further abuse and harm.

-Spongebob Genderpants

 

Sources:

Aulette, Judy Root, and Judith Wittner. Gendered Worlds. New York: Oxford University Press, 2012. Print.

Boys Don’t Cry. Kimberly Peirce. 1999.

Peterson, Latoya. “The Not-Rape Epidemic”. Gnds 125 Gender, Race and Popular Culture Book 1. Boston: Pearson Education Company, 2013. 135-144. Print

Steubenville: A Rape Culture

While my group members and I have chosen various mediums to discuss this month’s topic of sexual violence, I believe that our individual topics share a common denominator besides that of sexual violence. I believe that our individual topics, whether it is concerning sexual assault in India or in prisons, share similarity in how social and media responses have treated these violent assaults with too much levity. Levity, not in the sense that it is not being reported or ignored, but in that some of the responses chose to focus on the perspectives of the perpetrators, thus trivializing the ordeal of the victims.

Being a poor college student, living in the student ghetto housing without access to an operating TV, I rarely have time to watch the news or read about headlines across the nation. However, in the past few weeks, a few headlines managed to grab my attention, simply because of its pervasiveness on websites that I usually frequent (Tumblr, BuzzFeed etc.). These headlines reported the events of the Steubenville Rape Case, in which a 16 year old girl from Steubenville Ohio was repeatedly raped by two high school footballers, Trent Mays and Ma’lik Richmond. Mays and Richmond took the girl from party to party, where numerous videos and photos of the incidents were not only taken but also posted onto online social media sites. While the act of the rape and the amount of bystanders who witnessed the attack shocked and disgusted me, what was truly horrifying was the media’s coverage and the social response during and after the trial. Some of the social responses and media coverage exemplified elements of rape culture and reflected how patriarchy perpetuates our social framework.

Instead of questioning what environmental or social conditions encouraged Mays and Richmond to act out in such a violent way, people instead chose to marginalize the victim in order to justify what was done to her; “when what happens to women is marginalized, when beyond a shadow of doubt still isn’t enough, when your past, manner of dress, grade point average, or intoxication level are used to excuse the despicable acts of sexual violence inflicted upon you by another” (Peterson 142). This is a product of rape culture; where a patriarchal society has continual faith in the goodness of men over the words of women, and where a woman’s word is questioned and suspected while a man’s word is taken at face value. Demonstrably in the Steubenville Rape case, rape culture is the protectionist attitude that society holds over men. While both Mays and Richmond are perpetrators of the crime; they nonetheless evoke empathy and understanding because ultimately it was the girl’s fault for being too intoxicated, and thus the onus of whether or not rape occurs is entirely dependent on the female victim. This reflects how pervasive and internalised patriarchy is instilled in North American society, to the extent that rape has become justifiable on the grounds that it was the victim’s fault.

blog1

Social media outlets, by responding to the guilty verdict with sympathy for the two perpetrators, further reinforces the perception that men are not to blame, because they are themselves simply a victim of their biological natures. “The theory that men have drives that must be met at all costs is similar to popular notions of men’s sexual needs. This logic relieves men of responsibility for their violence (‘it’s only natural’) and makes women complicit in their own victimization” (Aulette & Wittner 271). This encourages slut-shaming because of the assumption that it is only “natural” for men to be sexually aggressive; it is women’s responsibility to never put herself in a position to be raped. Victim-blaming is an act of oppression. By restricting women to a certain modicum of behaviours and attitudes in order to avoid rape, victim blaming suppresses female agency and freedoms. Victim blaming also plays into social expectations of hypermasculinity, in that we as a society celebrates male dominance and how we recognise male dominance as the norm. It reinforces the misconception that because males are “naturally” dominant, they cannot be held accountable for their behaviour, whereas females are accountable for preventing potential violence done onto them.

blog2

Rape culture is nurtured and built, from the way boys and girls are socialised since birth to the behaviours that society expects from each respective gender. Inherently, “the fear of crime and of public violence is gendered” (Aulette & Wittner 262). Girls are taught from a very young age to stay away from strangers and dark alleyways, to always be aware of their surroundings, to behave in lady-like manners to dissuade inappropriate reciprocal behaviour from men, etc. This effectively enables girls and subsequently, women, to internalise the responsibility of rape; that whether or not rape occurs is entirely preventable. It creates a rape culture that allows men to excuse their behaviour and to refrain from taking responsibility for what they have done, that whoever the perpetrator may be, the girl ‘should have known better’.

blog

By focusing primarily on how the potential and the future of these boys have been ruined, people fail to recognise the extreme damage done to the victim and her future. Evidently, the futures of the two male perpetrators are placed at a higher importance than the future of the female victim. It trivializes the acts of violence and oppression that was done to her; it is like saying “sure, they may have raped a girl or two, but just think of the NFL possibilities!” A way in which society can stop the progression of rape culture and victim blaming is through education. From a young age, instead of telling young girls that prevention of rape is dependent on their actions, society ought to be discouraging aggressive behaviour from young boys and to teach them to respect others. Society as a whole should be teaching men not to rape instead of teaching women how to prevent rape.

-xoxo Gossip Girl

A Pressing Issue

In keeping with this month’s blog post theme of sexual violence, I would like to discuss the recent events that took place in India and how they relate to this serious issue.

The tourism industry of India has just taken a massive turn for the worse. This is not due to natural disasters, political instability or military conflict; it is due to sexual violence. This sexual violence in India has made headlines across the world recently as it seems it is getting worse. A recent Wall Street Journal poll stated that nearly “76%” of their respondents have said that India is not safe to travel too, specifically for western women because of this violence.

Sexual violence is so prevalent in India due to India’s social structure and the way they view and treat women in society. Women in India, and in many places around the world, are poorer, less powerful, and less able than men. Consequently, there are many reasons in Indian culture that support why there is such a large issue of sexual violence. Firstly, domestic violence is accepted as being normal behaviour. A UNICEF study found that approximately “55% of both boys and girls between the ages of 15-19 thought that wife-beating is justified”. This demonstrates that the majority of youth in India feel women are inferior to men. Additionally, there is also a stigmatization of rape victims with very little support for the problems they are experiencing. Many high ranking officials state that the victims brought it upon themselves due to the clothing they wore. These officials also encourage rape victims to drop cases and compromise with their assaulter because the judicial system is weak. This exposes many of the victims to “retraumatization” (Lecture 12); further increasing the pain and uselessness they feel. Finally, the most important reason for this rape accepting culture to exist is the overall poor status of women in India. It begins when they are children, where boys are fed better and are given more opportunities. Additionally, there is a high instance of sex-selective abortion which causes a high male to female ratio in the population. All of these factors have great importance when analyzing the way in which sexual violence takes place in this country and throughout the world.

The most documented incident of sexual violence in India recently was the “Delhi gang rape” of a woman last December. She was raped on a public bus and was killed in the process. The victim was 23 years old, a middle class physiotherapy intern and overall a normal woman. However, because women are treated so poorly in India, these men did not see her as an equal person. This is definitely not the only instance of this kind of thing happening, events like these happen in every country. Since this horrific incident, the Indian government has passed a bill to improve sexual assault legislation but it has done little to improve the situation. Simple laws will not be able to help get rid of this rape culture that is so prevalent in many countries, there has to be a change in the society itself.

I feel that this change in society must begin with the aiding of the victims. One of the most serious issues that need to be addressed is the constant “victim-blaming” that happens towards rape victims. As discussed in lecture, “women that act flirtatiously or dress in revealing clothes” hold responsibility and play a significant role in them getting raped. This discredits the severity of the issue, causing it to be seen as not important and therefore unnecessary to be changed. This is then directly supported by what we have studied in lecture in regards to society’s objectification and sexualisation of women. The positive in this regard however is that there are good changes, at least in the west, in regards to minimizing the objectification of women. As we saw in lecture 4, 19 magazine editors said they would refuse to work with women who had eating disorders or who were too young. The fashion giant “Vogue” also stated that they would not work with women who were too skinny. This is a small step in improving this perception of women but the real problem is that these societal changes have not taken place in developing countries such as India.

As a man, I feel we have a big role to play in helping the fight against sexual violence towards women. Joining with women in solidarity, men can help remove the stigmatization of rape and eliminate the rape culture that is prevalent in many countries, including India. This issue of sexual violence does not simply only concern women; we have an equal role in stopping it. By becoming more involved and challenging ourselves on the concepts of rape, men can help women gain more awareness for this serious issue and help change its perception around the world.

Dear-Society-sign-during-the-rally-for-the-Indian-rape-victim

Even though India has been in the news a lot recently for the serious sexual crimes that have been committed, it is important to realize that these issues are prevalent everywhere. India however, is an area where sexual violence is extremely prevalent due to a culture that degrades women and allows for sexual violence to occur. We must remember that all violence stems from the treatment of the victim in society and that in order to get rid of these horrible acts, we must always work to create equality in society.

– Carver Descartes

An Eye Opener

The General Question for our blogs this month is sexual assault, the current cases happening today, other places where this occurs in silence, and the humor that is associated with sexual assault especially in prisons.

Why is it that rape counselors believe that only one in fifty raped women report the crime of sexual violence to the police? (Gendered Worlds 268). Is it because it can be perceived as a joke? According to the article Why Does Popular Culture Treat Prison Rape as a Joke has some insight into how the issue of sexual assault in prison is silent and can be viewed as acceptable and humorous.

There is a new board game that the class read and learned about in lecture called “Don’t Drop the Soap” (Clark 2009). The purpose of this game is to fight through prison. This game is the first example of how rape in prison can be viewed as humorous. Board games and sexual assault should never be associated with each other because the idea of board games it to promote amusement. Sexual assault is a serious topic that should not be promoted as amusement. As mentioned a current issue in prisons today is the silence of rape in women’s prison. The Just Detention International (JDI) challenges perceptions, practices, and consequences of rape in prisons for 29 years now (Clark 2009). “Humor is part of cultural attitude that (prison) is the one place where rape is okay” (Clark 2009). However, sexual assault should not be perceived this way because after the act of sexual assault it causes the victim psychological issues for the remainder of their life. Ending the silence and the experiences of rape into social problems are early steps toward ending sexual violence (Gendered Worlds 278). Hollywood movies and late night talk shows play off the “Don’t Drop the Soap” (Clark 2009). Media allows the humor associated with sexual assault to be known as acceptable in society.

Women are not the only ones affected by sexual assault. Men usually don’t admit they are afraid of walking late at night or being alone, “however men who go to prison do fear sexual assault and they have the right to do so” (Gendered Worlds 287). In 2006 there was a reported 6,241 allegations of sexual violence in male prison (Gendered Worlds 287). This issue needs to be discussed, it is not humorous and the silence and acceptable standard view should not be existent. Society needs to realize that sexual assault happens to male and females.

More insight into Prison rape is that it is an example of “doing gender” which means victims are forced into sexual roles whom are then sexual targets of other prisoners. Once they get forced into these roles the reputation follows them. To escape being a target, prisoners agree to become the property of another prisoner who will protect them in exchange for sex and domestic labor (Gendered Worlds 287).

prison

Something needs to be done about this issue both for men and females in prison and in society today. I believe awareness is the first step as mentioned in Gendered Worlds. I was not aware of the extent sexual assault had on both genders and that it occurred in prison as much as it occurred in society. We need to support the survivors and eliminate the number of survivors increasing in the future.

-Ashley

Outweighing the Benefits of the Pornification of Poverty Media

Progression in racial diversity in terms of the popular media has become a lot more mainstream. In the past, black and white television would only consist of white actors and actresses. This week there was a discussion on media’s depiction on development in developing countries. I therefore feel that is appropriate that I talk about just that. Carver Descartes pointed out it is important to analyze the implications media has on the receiver. Subsequently, we have learned throughout the course to question popular media as well as the themes they infringe on us. The status quo is no longer something that we as students of the course look to without challenging it. However, what about racial stereotypes portrayed in media that is supposedly to help development? Are we to questions those? What effects do those have on the general population if any?

 

In trying to answer these questions, I have decided to re-watch these clips depicting development issues in places such as Africa. It is evident that the pornification of development issues is currently at its highest; the flies buzzing around children, who are too weak and impoverished to even move. The extreme conditions of these children and mothers make people want to immediately help, same as how porn would make people want to have sex. However, as discussed, the pornification of development issues merely makes people give their money to these world aid organizations. In terms of tackling actual poverty however, it does nothing. Out of curiosity, I decided to google “poor white countries”. Not to my surprise, the first was a Yahoo Answers page with the headline “Why aren’t there any poor white countries”. It is evident that our class is not the only ones who notice the racialization of poverty media. However, is this a choice made by the media? Or is this just because black Africans just so happen to be the poorest of the poor? I’ve thought about this long and hard and have come to a not so enlightening answer: yes and no. Yes, it is a choice made by the media, the media makes the decision on what to film in order to target their audience. However, black Africans alone aren’t the poorest. There are still people in states such as China, Mongolia and Albania who suffer immense poverty. The media however, just chooses not to depict them. Now we must question why the media chooses to enforce these existing stereotypes of impoverished black peoples.

 

Surely, this reinforcement of racial stereotypes in poverty media has some implication on our society. Whether people chose to believe that black Africans are the only ones in poverty can have spillover effects into other streams of media such as movies or in novels. However, are poverty ads depiction of black Africans really so horrible. The pornification does what the producers intended; entices people to donate. Therefore, looking at the bigger picture can we still justify challenging poverty commercials because of their pornification, or do the benefits of donations outweigh that of a “little white” stereotype?

 xDxDGenderdude

Happily Ever After

SpongeBob GenderPants raised the question of, “what other ideas does film and television portray that gives others a negative image?” The first idea that comes to mind is how Disney films display consistent heterosexual marriages. When one thinks of all the famous Disney princesses they always have a happily ever after ending with a prince. This consistent ending is an example of heteronormativity that, “relates to a worldview that promotes heterosexuality as the normal or preferred sexual orientation.” Heternormativity isvisible is Disney films because the preferred sexual orientation they are promoting is heterosexual.

This gives children a negative image because it will lead them to the impression that homosexuality is not tolerable in society. Except in today’s society we are vying for equality and acceptance for same sex relationships. Children at such a young age would not have the exposure to realize this positive shift that is occurring. Disney connects to children at such a young age to influence their mentality and views towards homosexuality.

Heteronormativity in Disney films can also send a negative message to children that they will not find their “happily ever after” if they do not have a heterosexual relationship. This is not a message Disney will want to continue to send out to the youth because it can result in a lot of stress for the child when they reach their adolescent years. One of the major causes for mental health is bullying that is happening towards homosexual adolescents. An answer on how to teach children acceptance at a young age is to bring their awareness to homosexuality in early years.

Reflecting on the mise-en-scene in Disney Films at the end of the story when a heterosexual relationship saves the day is always filled with energetic music, bright lighting, and everything around the couple comes to life. A scene that portraysthis mise-en-scene is the film Snow Whiteand the Seven Dwarfs (1937), when Prince Charming kisses the dead body of Snow White. The setting in the film quickly shifts from a quiet, dark, depressing mood, to an energetic, bright, lively scene. The reason for the happy ending was a connection in a heterosexual relationship. Would Disney create the same mise-en-scene if a female kissed Snow White?

snow white

When will Disney movies make this transition to displaying homosexual relationships? When they do, what will the reaction of their fan base result in? Will this transition continue? These are all questions that remain unanswered until the day a film demonstrates homosexuality.

This will be a well-needed change in the heteronormativity Disney displays today. Children will no longer be shown only one way to live happily ever after. Being told by their caregivers and role models, and now films that homosexual is a normal way to live will make the world a better place. I have hope there will be a film released in the near future promoting this relationship. I feel it is important to both children and adults to create a more accepting world.

Ashley

Django Chained to the Past

When analyzing aspects and themes in the media, I think that one of the most important things to realize is how large of an impact movies and TV shows can have on the general population. People today, especially children and young adults, are very prone to being influenced drastically by what they see on the screen. This is a great concern for those of us who have been taught to analyze these pieces of media and never take them at face value. Spongebob Genderpants expressed their ideas on the portrayal of natives in the “Game of Thrones” TV series. They made the point that the media loves to use stereotypes to portray natives as barbarians, an aspect that should no longer be associated with them in today’s society. One must always keep in mind that this kind of portrayal has an affect and delays the development of these disadvantaged cultures in attaining equality.

Similar to this effect is shown in Quentin Tarantino’s newest film, “Django Unchained”. The movie occurs in 1858, in the midst of the slavery era in the United States. It takes place in the south, where slavery was at its height. The public’s response to this film has been varied, some positive and some negative, but one fact remains true. This fact is that the constant reminder and portrayal of black people as slaves is a setback for racial equality no matter what. Although it is slightly accurate of what life was like back then, the fact remains that using this period as a form of entertainment does not help advance us as a society and reduce the racism against black people that is still prevalent today. This movie is a perfect example of cultural appropriation. It has a white director and primarily a white cast and crew creating a movie that focuses on the worst time in black history. A well respected black director, Spike Lee, has also come out in saying that he was very offended at Tarantino’s overuse of the n-word and that the movie was “disrespectful to his ancestors”. Although not the opinion of the majority, this is a perfect example of how detrimental this type of entertainment can be to other cultures, whether they are black or not.

In the movie black people are also portrayed as vengeful, angry and barbaric. Tarantino demonstrates this all in one scene where he has the main character, played by Jamie Foxx, kill nearly ten white slavers, including women, in a vicious bloodbath at the main slaver’s mansion. The movie focuses on the blood and gore that result from the encounter and uses it to portray Foxx as a barbaric animal, something similarly done to the Dothraki in “Game of Thrones”. Another aspect of the movie that supports this barbaric idea is the business of slave fighting that is so prevalent in the film. The main slaver, Candie, fights black people like animals until the death for entertainment. This is the height of dehumanization and barbarism. Compounding to this fact is that all of the Black people in the movie rarely speak. They are silent, weak and have no control over their lives. This is true for all but two black characters in the movie. Jamie Foxx, playing Django the protagonist, does demonstrate independence and power but is overshadowed by vengeance and sadness. One of the major antagonists of the film, played by Samuel L. Jackson, is a black man who allies himself with the head slaver. Jackson is a traitor, a man with no sense of respect or kindness for his fellow people who are suffering. Ultimately throughout the whole film, we are given almost no opportunity to see black people in a truly equal light.

 Image

Other scenes In Django that visually show the sadness and barbarism are very easy to find. There is a scene where one man gets eaten by dogs, possibly one of the lowest forms of death that one can think of. The mise en scene of this scene tells you everything you need to know. It presents the one black man getting eaten by dogs whilst other black slaves stand around helpless. He is shown as being weak, with very little teeth and in old raged cloths.

 Image

In spite of all this, many people say that this is the way the movie had to be done because it was representing what life was like in those times. However, the question I would like to pose is as follows; why do these times of pure evil have to be focused on and portrayed over and over again in our mass media? The age of slavery was one of the darkest and most evil times in recent history and constantly depicting it as a form of entertainment cannot possibly lead to us moving past it any faster. 

– Carver Descartes

Exoticizing Ethnicity and Race

While western media has begun to incorporate racial diversity and representation, in TV shows or in advertisements, the efficacy of this incorporation is lost in the context that these racially diverse characters are placed in. Obvious or blatant racism and racialisation may no longer be observed, yet more subtle forms of it certainly exists that nonetheless exercises influential impact (52 Pearson). Women in magazines and pornography are systemically categorized according to their race or cultural heritage; Asian women into one category and Latina women into another. This effectively forces depictions of racially diverse women into highly exoticized niches, where their exoticism is fetishized and eroticized. By doing so, these women are demoted to an object which men may then project their desires upon and confined singularly to their racial definition.

Advertisements also tend to make the blatant and racist mistake of portraying non-white women in what advertisers believe to be their “natural habitat”. Black women are often dressed in animal print, alluding to the African Sahara and its primitive nature, which only serves to dehumanize the women that are wearing the clothes. Sometimes, black women are deliberately placed next to photos of wild animals, blatantly comparing them to an animal, exoticizing them as wild and savage, which further dehumanizes the female subject.

In the following front cover for the magazine Harpers Bazaar, model Chanel Iman is depicted wearing a turban.

Turbans a style of headdress that is prevalently worn by people that reside in the North African and Middle Eastern regions, and by people within the international diasporas of these regional cultures. That is not to say that all people who reside in or trace ancestry to these regions typically wear turbans. However, it is the image that western media often portrays; that all North African or Middle Eastern people look, dress and act a certain way, regardless of the vast diversity of physical appearance, culture and religion within these regions. This caters to the systemic notion in western nations that only white citizens are capable of individuality and complexity, while the foreign “other” is characterised by simplistic cultural affiliations and is one dimensional. In the case of the Harpers Bazaar cover, the model is poised in a way that is congruent with what advertisers believe to be what black women ought to look like and how they look in their ‘natural habitat’ of sub-Sahara. It makes little to no effort in illustrating the intersectionality of a racially diverse woman working in a western industry that glorifies Anglo-Saxon beauty or that Chanel Iman is not only African American but also Korean American. The cover debases her to nothing more than an institutionalized stereotype of what African American beauty ought to look like.

A 1986 commercial by the French fashion house Yves Saint Laurent for the highly successful fragrance named Opium is a prime example of how the depiction of culture can have an immeasurable impact on stereotypes and desensitization. The premise of the commercial is that the perfume is so good that it is addictive, like the opium drug. The use of opium was prominent in late 19th century China, essentially crippling the working ability of a large portion of the population. The smoking of opium was introduced by British traders, who were naturally furious when the Chinese government placed heavy import taxes on opium to circumvent the heavy reliance that the Chinese population had on it. This would eventually lead to the Opium Wars which spanned a period of nearly two decades. Yet YSL still chose to locate the commercial in what the audience can easily assume to be China; the commercial itself is shrouded in a cloud of smoke, presumably from opium, and the decorations within the commercial pervades a sense of hyper-Orientalism.

Through the depiction of hyper-Orientalism, the commercial effectively exoticizes Chinese culture. The commercial leads to an objectification of the historical context and the plight of two decades worth of suffering and warfare. By exoticizing opium and the negative impact it had on Chinese culture, the advertisement dehumanizes and reduces human suffering into the form of a mass-produced fragrance. By dehumanizing the historical context, advertisers can then feel little qualms about comparing the addiction of a fragrance to the addiction of a nation that lead to a war which resulted in exorbitant amounts of deaths. Because “Oriental” people are generally and systemically categorized as the foreign “other”, the significance of their suffering would be inferior to the importance of western hegemonic societies. Therefore, their deaths and suffering can be transformed into commercialism, and trivialized into a brand that can be bought and sold. Imagine for a moment if a brand decided to market its product in relation to the events of the Holocaust. The brand and marketing strategy would almost be immediately and severely condemned for its sheer insensitivity and intolerance. Yet, what makes commercials like the one for YSL’s Opium perfume not only perfectly acceptable, but also successful?

xoxo, Gossip Girl

Accepting the Barbarian

The portrayal of people of colour in television and film is often not accurately representative of actual culture. Disney movies are often brought up to support this argument and movies like Pocahontas, Aladdin and The Hunchback of Notre Dame. The representation of Native Americans and First Nations especially become over exaggerated caricatures of people that are in touch with nature and choose to live in an uncivilized manner. Although many native cultures had extreme advancements before Europeans ever came into the picture, they are hardly represented as such. Instead, native peoples are shown as barbaric and needing of western education and aid.

HBO’s Game of Thrones is a prime example of this poor portrayal of native people. The barbaric Dothraki are the focus here. The first encounter with the Dothraki people in Game of Thrones is when Daenerys, a princess of the fallen Targaryen royal regime, is preparing to meet Khal Drogo, the Dothraki king. Viserys, Daenerys’ brother has betrothed his sister to Khal Drogo in oder to gain the military support of the Dothraki.

Viserys is a wicked man, frequently sexually harassing and emotionally abusing his sister, yet she would rather marry Viserys than an uncivilized Dothraki king. Throughout this series, the Dothraki are referred to as ‘savages’ yet no one, let alone Daenerys towards the end of the first season, questions this. It is accepted that, because these people are good warriors, that they are brutish and fiercely loyal only to themselves.

When Daenerys first meets her soon to be husband, Khal Drogo, the mis-en-scene tells viewers everything they need to know. The siblings are standing in a beautiful garden outside of a building where birds are chirping, with crisp clothes, fresh faces and flowing white blond hair. They, despite being exiled, still resemble royalty. They are white, young, surrounded by light. The Dothraki soldiers and Khal Drogo come thundering in under a shadowed bridge in a stampede of hooves, dirt and darkness. Daenerys is marketed as fragile in this scene, wearing a pale, sheer gown that shows off the curves of her young figure. It emphasizes her daintiness and fragility, yet her seeming unawareness of this makes her seem innocent and naive.

Targaryen-daenerys-targaryen

As Khal Drogo storms in and glares down at her from his horse, the scene plays it off as Daenerys is the childlike victim of this brute’s intentions. He is a typical caricature of a savage with dark skin, war paint, huge muscular physique and dark threatening eye makeup.

Dany-Drogo-daenerys-and-drogo-23281325-1363-2048

Khal Drogo later brings Daenerys to his village where a wedding celebration is hosted. The scenery is desolate and dusty set on a rocky backdrop, as compared to the rich buildings draped with cloth and gold that were shown as the Targaryen’s accommodations. In this highly graphic scene, many atrocious stereotypes of native culture are shared. On one instance, two men engage in a battle to the death over a woman. The men are all bare-chested and the women scantily clad, often bare breasted, and draped in leather straps that have no purpose more than to accentuate their physiques. Daenerys and Khal Drogo watch over as the women and men engage in extremely sexually implicit dancing. One man visibly throws down a woman and forces rough sexual acts with her, which she seems to enjoy. The Dothraki people dance with no abandon and seem almost intoxicated with ritual and wildness. All the while, Daenerys, the educated and civilized one, stares with horror while Drogo mutters and smiles with glee.

When others in the show are betrothed to be wed, no expense is spared in planning for the wedding celebrations. The Dothraki celebration, however, shows images of rotting meat platters with flies swarming around and mysterious articles of food that look remarkably like meaty animal skulls.

The Dothraki people seem to communicate with chants, goading hollers and grunts, rather than use words. The men engage in mob mentality where they yell to imply masculinity and cheer on violent and sexual acts. The women seem to hardly attempt to communicate, only succumb to the desires of the men. When the Dothraki do speak their language, it consists of abrupt phrases that come across as harsh, unfeeling and uneducated. Khal Drogo, when engaging in sexual acts with Daenerys, uses only force to inform her of his needs. He throws her around and bends her to his will, barely uttering a word, allowing his force and muscles to do the communicating.

tumblr_lmcneqAetS1qis07wo1_500

The traditions of the Dothraki are also exaggerated versions of native practices. This includes scalping, and fighting for entertainment. It is explained that the Dothraki males are born warriors and grow their hair long. As punishment for losing a fight, whether it be with a fellow Dothraki or with another, their long ponytail, adorned with bells and knots, is hacked off with a blunt knife. This is to serve as an embarrassment of defeat that they must bear with them. Khal Drogo, of course, is the fiercest fighter in the land and has never lost a single fight, so his hair grows long. Another tradition of these people, as discovered later in season one, is the expectation that a woman will throw herself on the burning funeral pyre of her fallen lover. The expectation that women will sacrifice themselves because they have no reason to live when they have no man to monitor them is absurd to us, yet not given a second glance in this show.

Game of Thrones argues that women can be bought, sold and traded and are to be ruled by men. Stereotypes and false ideas about non-white, non-wealthy people are heavily enforce and added upon as well. Native people are portrayed as brutish and uneducated. This show, though highly popular, reintroduces ideas that were slowly becoming transformed in today’s society. This begs the question, why? Why would HBO and other media play into unfair pictures of society that is different from the accepted white, western lifestyle? What other ideas does film and television portray that give others a negative image?

-SpongeBob GenderPants